Why HR Is Failing Neurodivergent Employees—and What CEOs Need to Know

Why HR Is Failing Neurodivergent Employees—and What CEOs Need to Know

HR loves to talk about inclusion. But when it comes to neurodivergence in the workplace, the gap between intention and impact is wide—and growing. CEOs looking to drive innovation, engagement, and performance can't afford to let HR continue operating in the dark.

Neurodivergence: The Inclusion Test HR Keeps Failing

Neurodivergent employees—those with ADHD, autism, dyslexia, anxiety, and more—are often among the most creative, analytical, and innovative thinkers on any team. Yet they’re also among the most misunderstood, mismanaged, and overlooked.

The reason? HR systems are built for sameness.

From standardized interviews to rigid behavioral expectations, HR’s version of “fairness” often means treating everyone the same—when true inclusion demands the opposite.

A System Built for Conformity, Not Capability

Most HR teams are operating from outdated, compliance-first playbooks. Their processes aren’t just slow—they’re biased, shallow, and inflexible. Here’s how this hurts neurodivergent employees:

  • Rigid performance evaluations penalize those who communicate or process information differently.

  • Recruitment practices filter out top talent due to nontraditional career paths or atypical interview behavior.

  • Coaching and feedback systems often ignore or misinterpret neurodivergent needs, labeling them as “difficult” or “uncoachable.”

And the worst part? HR often doesn’t realize they’re doing it.

The Capability Crisis in HR

Let’s be blunt: many HR professionals are not equipped to support neurodivergent talent. They aren’t trained to recognize invisible disabilities, let alone advocate for inclusive systems that actually work.

The consequence? Neurodivergent employees are:

  • Hired last.

  • Promoted rarely.

  • Coached punitively.

  • And too often, they leave.

Not because they couldn’t perform—but because the system was never built with them in mind.  

CEOs: You Can’t Fix What You Don’t Understand

There’s a dangerous myth in corporate leadership: that HR is a strategic partner. In reality, many HR teams are reactive, compliance-driven, and deeply disconnected from business outcomes. For neurodivergent inclusion to become real, CEOs must first understand how far off the mark HR truly is.

That means asking hard questions:

  • Are we ahead of, behind or on par with our competitors when it comes to innovation & creative problem solving?

  • What training does my HR team have on neurodivergence in the workplace?  And what data points speak to the pulse of the neurodivergent worker in my organization?

  • What changes have we made to the environment to be more conducive to the neurodivergent worker?  How do we know it's working?

  • Is our recruitment process accessible and even more important, attractive to neurodivergent candidates?  How do we know?

  • Do our performance metrics account for diverse communication styles and workflows?

  • Are we coaching leaders to manage difference—or suppress it?

If your answer is “I’m not sure,” then you have work to do.

Inclusion Isn’t About Being Nice. It’s About Being Effective.

Hiring, retaining, and growing neurodivergent talent isn’t charity—it’s strategy. Inclusive systems lead to higher innovation, lower turnover, and stronger engagement. But only when done right.

This starts with acknowledging the system is broken—and that HR might be the reason.

💡 Want real, practical strategies for creating workplaces where neurodivergent talent thrives?
Join the Slaying Ordinary mailing list for monthly insights, exclusive content, and powerful resources that challenge the status quo and elevate inclusive leadership.

👉 Subscribe to our monthly newsletter and start building a workplace that works for everyone.

Back to blog

Collections